|
>>
|
b1f0e2.jpg
Glitter Wish
b1f0e2
8-31-2011 IRC Chatlog, very interesting info. Bob suggested we might want to update wiki
<MrTT> the current consensus is to just drive away
<TheBeardiestBob> Anyone have any questions?
<TheBeardiestBob> Like, for example, whether attempting to drive away would royally fuck you?
<TheBeardiestBob> Just an example.
<MrTT> we do
<MrTT> i posted that i wanted to ask einrik if he knows whether it is possible to inadvetedly violate a soul oath
<MrTT> what the results for such would be if it is possible
<MrTT> and whether he thinks our interpretation is valid within the rules
<TheBeardiestBob> Oh well that's simple
<MrTT> i get the feeling that if armas doesn't go in there and kill whomever that einher is he will meet a bad end
<TheBeardiestBob> a soul oath that is broken will slay the one that breaks it
<TheBeardiestBob> simple as that
<TheBeardiestBob> that's why it's called a soul oath
<MrTT> ah
<TheBeardiestBob> because it holds each deal maker's soul as collateral to fulfilling the oath
<MrTT> a mini update with einrik's answer to that question might be VERY relevant to most people's voting I think...
<TheBeardiestBob> Too drunk for that
<TheBeardiestBob> tomorrow I will update
<TheBeardiestBob> but now?
<TheBeardiestBob> Drunk as fuck
<MrTT> can i go and post this, as the answer that einrik would be giving?
<MrTT> as in "I asked bob what would einrik say if Armas asked him whether it is possible to break a soul oath and what the result of that would be if it is"
<MrTT> and bob said einrik would say that breaking a soul oath results in instant death
<TheBeardiestBob> What, that breaking a soul oath claims the soul of the one that breaks it>?
<MrTT> yes
<TheBeardiestBob> Problem is Armas doesn't know that
<TheBeardiestBob> so why would you post it?
<TheBeardiestBob> He needs a reason to know a given thing
<MrTT> the reason is that we are going to ask einrik before driving away...
<MrTT> posted that earlier and I think 2 people upvoted the question IIRC
<TheBeardiestBob> But that still does not resolve the issue
<TheBeardiestBob> How would Armas know?
<TheBeardiestBob> and if Armas wouldn't know
<TheBeardiestBob> what legitimate reason is there for this knowledge to influence posters?
<MrTT> now he doesn't know, but as soon as he asks Einrik he will know
<MrTT> >Is it even possible to break a soul swear or will I just find myself unable to do so?
<MrTT> Before you do anything else, ask Einrik if he knows that answer. He probably would know more then you about that and it is worth knowing what is at stake here. If it is possible to violate then ask if he knows what the results would be if you do break it. Do you walk out on your powers, or should you expect something worse?
<MrTT> If einrik doesn't know, maybe SM would be able to clarify... make sure you never insinuate that you wish to break a deal, rather that you are concerned about unintentional violations. Although you are also curious to know about intentional violations but not for purpose of doing it yourself.
<MrTT> If we do accidentally break the deal, we clarify to Ogrimmir and SM, that we acted within what we thought was the confines of the deal.
<MrTT> And it got upvotes
<MrTT> so basically next update, before armas actually drives away, he should ask einrik... einrik answers "you die and your soul is claimed as collatoral if you violate a soul oath"... at which point the "drive away" plan gets a wrench thrown into it
<MrTT> my current plan is, once armas gets the answer, he pays SM to give him a tracer on that einher. then drives away, that way his ass is covered for sure
<TheBeardiestBob> Quite frankly, from a player perspective plan B is the 'safest' as while it costs more, no matter how the rules ultimately lay, you are safely outside them.
<TheBeardiestBob> It a 'you pay' but also a 'complete immunity to possible ramifications outside the ones you know and are prepared for (soul damage).'
<MrTT> but, plan B relies on the current situation NOT being a meeting yet
<MrTT> same as plan A
<MrTT> whether we drive away now, or have shadowbro swap with us now, meet him, then drive away, we are still going out of his presence
<MrTT> or we are not, depending on whether where we are now counts as presence or not
<TheBeardiestBob> but, should the interpretation of the rules be a worst case scenario, plan A results in Armas' death. No matter HOW the rules are interpreted, by plan B Armas never actually encounters the Einher-as if he drives away, at some level he acknoweledges that, while not knowing WHO the Einher is-he has a damn good idea.
<TheBeardiestBob> While swapping with Shadowbro can easily manipulate previously used self deception to stay clear of such danger thoughts.
<MrTT> I still cannot fathom why swapping with shadowbro now doesn't mean the exact same thing
<MrTT> ... wait... what if einrik knocks us out and shadowbro takes our memories of the encounter?
<TheBeardiestBob> Because Armas can decieve himself into thinking he should give Shadowbro a chance to socialize, a chance to grow as a person-an attempt to feel good for having 'humanized' his shadow, an action both displaying dominance by commanding it, and empathy for 'granting' emotion.
<TheBeardiestBob> he can make himself think he's doing this for a personal gain as a result of a possible scenario
<TheBeardiestBob> rather than 'I know who the Einher is in all but fact'
<TheBeardiestBob> That's how damn useful a lvl 6 social trait is
<MrTT> so, he will manipulate himself into making this a non-issue?
<MrTT> huh
<TheBeardiestBob> ...But again, frankly you guys have been using the Trait relatively shittily.
<TheBeardiestBob> not a non-issue, so much as a scenario to self improve, rather than the identification of a probably familial Einher.
<TheBeardiestBob> Hey Al
<TheBeardiestBob> no update tonight as I got back late drunk as fuck
<TheBeardiestBob> and have smoked like a chimney since there
<MrTT> hi Al
<AlratanMobile> Hi guys
<MrTT> alratan, you are logged in twice
<MrTT> hey bob, we were thinking... someone brought up that a bear gall bladder goes for, IRL, 200,000$ a pound... that is just one of the rare animal parts
<TheBeardiestBob> problem is that the Magical item market is a niche market, and within that niche market, the majority are aware most merchants can abuse the Other Side / Nevernever's principles to farm materials en masse.
<MrTT> so we were thinking, how much would a troll heart or phoenix heart could be worth... millions? what if we call lo fang and say "we are thinking of buying, what do you have in far of rarer magical meats"... if he gives low price, then we found a new source to buy extra meats. if he gives a high price we can go "shit for this much I should be hunting, what percentage of that figure can I expect for what I bring in?"
<MrTT> well, if they ARE abusing the market in such a manner then we should be able to buy cheap
<MrTT> so its a win-win for us
<MrTT> we either sell or we buy, depending on price ranges
<MrTT> "<TheBeardiestBob> because it holds each deal maker's soul as collateral to fulfilling the oath" - wait, does that mean that if Og inadventedly violates his terms of the deal armas gets Og's soul?
<TheBeardiestBob> Haha
<TheBeardiestBob> if only you knew
<TheBeardiestBob> short answer no
<TheBeardiestBob> and you have to work out long answer yourself
<TheBeardiestBob> otherwise it defeats the purpose
<MrTT> i wonder though
<MrTT> mmm, i bet its not enough to just say "I soul swear"... you need magic to bind it
<MrTT> i wonder how much a soul is worth
<MrTT> and whether we can get armas to make deals where other people soul swear to do something...
<MrTT> So, we are sure Og is not Odin right?
<TheBeardiestBob> Swearing on your soul is easy
<MrTT> or Thor, or Loki
<TheBeardiestBob> making it more than words is hard as fuck
<MrTT> awww, so no "armas the soul merchant" then?
<TheBeardiestBob> but if you do it, you've basically enslaved someone in a confined geas.
<TheBeardiestBob> You can see the use of that.
<TheBeardiestBob> or you are enslaved
<TheBeardiestBob> with soul oaths
<TheBeardiestBob> SOMEONE is getting bound
<TheBeardiestBob> that's kind of the original point of them,
<MrTT> it seems almost like a trap... something that is more beneficial for you to get the other person to fail to adhere to their side of the bargin
<MrTT> cause once they do, their soul is yours
<TheBeardiestBob> you guys should be happy I am at that optimal level of high and drunk, as I am freely giving out world principles for GfH I normally wouldn't, that would frankly be well suited for entry to the wike
<TheBeardiestBob> wiki
<TheBeardiestBob> and FRRRRRANKY!!
<TheBeardiestBob> Well, consider the fae
<TheBeardiestBob> they are bound to the truth, and upholding their deals, unless you break them first
<MrTT> i get a feeling SM will be in real trouble if we mention his accidental violation of the deal
<TheBeardiestBob> so of course they would have to learn to work within such constraints
<TheBeardiestBob> they are sapient, intelligent beings
<TheBeardiestBob> why would they LIKE being bound to certain patterns?
<TheBeardiestBob> So when they see others acting outside what they can do
<TheBeardiestBob> they attempt to adapt it
<TheBeardiestBob> have been doing this for quite some time
<MrTT> ah, the "only a mortal may change the balance of the courts" thing
<TheBeardiestBob> not so much that
<TheBeardiestBob> as supernatural origin beings can do it
<TheBeardiestBob> but usually only the really heavy hitters
<TheBeardiestBob> the ones that get to make their own choices, basically
<TheBeardiestBob> wheras mortals/humans
<TheBeardiestBob> EVERY ONE OF THEM
<TheBeardiestBob> has that
<MrTT> wait, if Og DOES gain armas' soul from armas failing to uphold his deal... well armas' soul is now closely related to waitiri... i get a feeling that gives Og power over waitiri
<TheBeardiestBob> that's humanities one saving grace, considering their relative perceptual, physical and spiritual shittiness.
<TheBeardiestBob> Not only can the freely make their own choices-an immensce thing-they all are... habituatable
<TheBeardiestBob> that's the biggest thing humans have
<TheBeardiestBob> not free will
<TheBeardiestBob> not adabtability
<TheBeardiestBob> Just the ability to slowly make anything the norm
<TheBeardiestBob> and make it regular, unremarkable-something expected and hardly regarded, but utterly believed in.
<MrTT> does that mean, that humans can alter the rules that bind the fae in such a manner?
<MrTT> by making something mundane enough that the fae can now do it?
<MrTT> via shared belief?
<TheBeardiestBob> That's how Liches happen, that's how Vampires started, that's how werewolves started-and ultimately yes MrTT, but not on an individual scale
<TheBeardiestBob> not yes to your last two blurbs
<MrTT> yes, yes to the "humans as a whole (not as individuals" can alter the rules by collective belief... and that is how you have vampires, and liches, and werewolves.
<MrTT> mmm, what about dragons? did collective human belief bring those about too?
<MrTT> and wizards?
<TheBeardiestBob> no and no
<TheBeardiestBob> dragons exist as the epitome of magic integration to physical systems-the perfect apex predator, if you will
<TheBeardiestBob> But Wizards
<TheBeardiestBob> wizards are like just stumbling onto antimatter and super-lightspeed physics simultaneously-something so radical that it defies normal progression. Dragons originally had everything-but Mortals came along, brought with them their rare Wizards... and their Gods.
<TheBeardiestBob> Some dragons are still a bit miffed about that.
<TheBeardiestBob> I'm signing off soon for sleep
<TheBeardiestBob> so if there's more questions
<TheBeardiestBob> ask them now
<MrTT> yea, what if we bought a tracer spell from SM like I suggested as an ass cover?
<MrTT> It seems to me like it would work
<MrTT> since, if sensing him counts, then we don't stop knowing where he is
<TheBeardiestBob> you can't get it without meeting in person to recieve it
<TheBeardiestBob> so catch 22
<AlratanMobile> Another question, does the strength of he donater matter for how powerful a winter bloodline we get by eating their heart
<MrTT> aww man... so can't have Einrik retrieve a hair of his without meeting him and use it to cast a tracer?
<TheBeardiestBob> No, and no.
<AlratanMobile> Or use a blood based tracer that detects relatives?
<TheBeardiestBob> As the person you kill acts as the spark of the bloodline
<TheBeardiestBob> not the foundation
<MrTT> so if we do kill this einher
<cUP> One question before you go
<MrTT> ask ogrimir to compound our bloodline, and eat his heart. we get ourselves the bloodline as good as killing an experienced einher
<MrTT> good to know
<cUP> The Einher we fought was able to discern the magical strength of our weapons enough to tell that Tartalo's hammer was the strongest
<TheBeardiestBob> your question?
<AlratanMobile> Why then do we get a better bloodline for Markku's heart than from any other valk's
<cUP> Does this mean that the Einher have inherit magical sensing more than just sensing enemies of their order?
<cUP> Some sort of general magic perception?
<TheBeardiestBob> Because Markku is recursive rule of three augmented. And cUP that is in fact correct, as they are ultimately designed to become magical spiritual beings they are more sensitive to magical and spiritual matters.
<cUP> Well that's nice
<MrTT> recursive loops of gaining power? awesome!
<cUP> Guess with Sami and Einher together our sensing issues will be a thing of a past
<MrTT> its like, powergaming in D&D Where the DM actually DOES allow you to be punpun :P
<MrTT> or chain-gating
<TheBeardiestBob> problem is that only make sit more likely major leagers with pay attention to you
<TheBeardiestBob> make IT more likely
<cUP> Odd side question, do Vampires grow hair? We were discussing this earlier. I hold that since their biological functions have basically stopped that aside from regenerating what once was they wouldn't grow more.
<MrTT> but counter argument is that without it they will all become bald, and they are already dead and regenerating impossible to regrow damage via magic
<AlratanMobile> A question, to use so
<MrTT> not via biology
<TheBeardiestBob> they do if they personally percieve their hair as 'injured'
<AlratanMobile> meone's heart as a spark, do they have to die
<AlratanMobile> Or can you cut it out and then have them healed?
<MrTT> ... are you thinking bargining with markku?
<TheBeardiestBob> Ah, you have to eat the heart for it to act as a spark
<AlratanMobile> Yes
<TheBeardiestBob> there's not that many ways to get around what that does to someone, cutting out and eating their heart
<TheBeardiestBob> and with that.
<TheBeardiestBob> good night
<AlratanMobile> But we know people who can regrow other people's organs
<cUP> Night
<MrTT> night
<cUP> As far as I know Markku can't
<MrTT> can't yet
<cUP> So you would have to rig a system for him to regrow it fairly quickly
<MrTT> but if we arrange for him to be able to
<cUP> Figure that out and then we'll start talking
<MrTT> instant heart regrowth potion
<AlratanMobile> Doony's regen is artificial
<MrTT> whoa it is? i thought it was natural
<cUP> TMI looked it up
<MrTT> also, didn't bob hint that eating doonie might cause a recursive power loop with our regeneration?
<cUP> In myth his regeneration was granted to him
<cUP> Same goes for in quest, but a lot of mythology was self written.
<MrTT> thanks for clarifying
<cUP> So pretty much anything but Bob confirmed things are iffy regarding him
<MrTT> also, actually bob said "regenerator meat + regeneration will cause a loop" but we already ate a lot of regenerator meat, its REALLY good for us but not infinite power good
|